We sat around their kitchen table with bottles of cold water and talked. He was in obvious need of medical attention, yet the fraternity brothers treated him with a callousness bordering on the sadistic. The parents of Timothy Piazza, the Penn State student who died while pledging for the fraternity Beta Theta Pi, have reached a settlement with the fraternity's national organization over the 19-year-old's death in 2017. But Beta Theta Pi turned his life around. Beta Theta Pi (ΒΘΠ), commonly known as Beta, is a North American social fraternity that was founded in 1839 at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio.One of North America's oldest fraternities, it currently consists of 118 active chapters and 20 colonies in the United States and Canada. The president of the college or university where the tragedy occurred will make bold statements about ensuring there is never another fraternity death at his institution. The now-banned fraternity Beta Theta Pi filed a lawsuit against Penn State and university officials on June 21, claiming that blame was placed on the Chapter for the February 2017 death of pledge Timothy Piazza to deflect from the university’s failures. And all of us are co-authors of these grim facts, as we grant both the fraternities and their host institutions tax-exempt status and allow them to carry on year after year with little change. Investigators are now looking for video evidence from inside the house. “They’re going to get me fucked up,” he texts his girlfriend, and then he pulls closed the door of his college apartment for the last time. The IFC claims that neither it nor St. Moritz retains any records from that night. But he is resilient, incredibly so. It has also permanently banned Beta Theta Pi from campus. He has put up a valiant, almost incredible fight for his life, but by now he has lost that fight. Rizzo sends a group text: “Tim Piazza might actually be a problem. When the nickname came to the attention of a teacher and his coach, the other players claimed that it was meant to be affectionate. It was full night now, and the rain had stopped. “I lost my future,” he told me. He learned—via, of all things, a college fraternity—how to exert self-control. Evelyn, who is petite and has long, ringleted hair—a lighter shade of red than Tim’s—was in shorts and a T‑shirt. This was best answered in the four planks of the campaign. He was coming out to show that he had nothing to hide, but I knew he was not prepared for the hardest question I had for him, which I would return to over and over again: Why hadn’t Beta Theta Pi taken the simple, obvious steps that would have saved Tim Piazza’s life? BELLFONTE, CENTRE COUNTY, Pa. -- (WPMT) -- Following a three-month long investigation the Centre County District Attorney announced Friday that Beta Theta Pi and 18 people have been charged in connection to the death of Pennsylvania State … I visited Jim and Evelyn Piazza on a lush New Jersey evening in July, when a summer rain was falling on the wide lawns and large houses of their neighborhood in Hunterdon County, one of the wealthiest areas in the United States. Usually they will also sue the fraternity, at which point they will discover how thoroughly these organizations have indemnified themselves against culpability in such deaths. Nor will it comment on a fact that The Daily Collegian reported: that the checkers were not full-time security guards, but Penn State kids who were working part-time for St. Moritz. In 2004, the university initiated a program it called Greek Pride: A Return to Glory, which was intended “to eliminate negative behavior within Greek organizations.” Many meetings were held, but nothing much seems to have come of them. His eyes are half open; his skin is cold to the touch; he is unnaturally pale. For most of their long history, fraternities pretty much did as they pleased. Looking back at the past two decades at Penn State, we see a university grappling with its fraternity problem in ways that pitted concerned administrators against a powerful system, and achieving little change. The story of black members of historically white fraternities is a complex one. Photographs had surfaced of some members of the wrestling team apparently being hazed: They were in their underwear with 40-ounce beer bottles duct-taped to their hands. This time the dead student left a final testimony, a vivid, horrifying, and inescapable account of what happened to him and why. Because the culprits are also relatively affluent white suburban kids, there is no need to fear pandering to the racial bias that favors stories about this type of victim. Penn State President Eric Barron said in a statement Friday that Beta Theta Pi was situated on private property and claimed to be a model fraternity, but it was "no model." The renovations were largely complete by the winter of 2007, and almost immediately the members began to trash the house. He was Catholic, old-school, elaborately respectful of players’ mothers—and eager to wrest their sons away and turn them into men, via the time-honored, noncoddling, masculine processes of football. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone. Two brothers sit on Tim’s legs to keep him from moving. One of the mansions he built for himself in California, in the San Gabriel Valley, has an underground firing range; a million-gallon, temperature-controlled trout pond; an oak-paneled elevator; and “Venetian plaster masterpieces throughout.” Similarly, his vision for the refurbished Beta house was like something out of a movie about college. By now Tim is “thrashing and making weird movements,” according to the grand-jury presentment. The public often interprets the “closing” of a fraternity as a decisive action. Davis then turns to the Beta brothers near Timothy and becomes very animated, again pointing at his head and then at Tim.”, The presentment states that when the brothers told Davis that Tim had fallen down the basement stairs, he became, Davis then sought out Ed Gilmartin, the vice president of the chapter: “The camera captures Davis gesturing once more, referring repeatedly to his head and pointing at Timothy.” Davis testified that Gilmartin told him he was crazy and “claimed the other brothers were kinesiology and biology majors,” so Davis’s word “meant nothing to him when compared to theirs.”, I sat with Kordel Davis this summer in the cacophonous food court in Philadelphia’s Reading Terminal Market, and we talked about that moment. Beta Theta Pi at Penn State University is suspended after the death of a student. I didn’t even know where I was. By now he has somehow lost his jacket and tie, and his white shirt has ridden up, revealing a strange, dark bruise on his torso. A young man walks into the frame and approaches the couch where Tim is lying, still unconscious. This extraordinary action occurs in the context of a continuing criminal investigation into the death of Penn State sophomore Timothy Piazza. It ended, finally, with what looked like a significant defeat: The most-serious charges—of involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault—were dropped. In 1997, five members of a fraternity showed up at University Health Services with what the physician there strongly suspected were hazing injuries; in the ominous phrase of the director of Health Services, the injuries had been caused by “something that someone else was doing to them.” The president of the university at the time, Graham Spanier (who is currently fighting a jail sentence resulting from his role in the Sandusky scandal), became involved. Another piece of ongoing Penn State litigation involves a student at the Altoona campus named Marquise Braham, who pledged Phi Sigma Kappa as a freshman in 2013. Text messages from members’ cellphones had been entered into evidence, and included this exchange between two brothers at the time of the fall 2016 initiation: As people have since explained it to me, the Shep Test itself is little more than a quiz about Beta Theta Pi history, but it’s one part of a night of mind games and physical punishments. With pillowcases over their heads, they were paddled, leaving bruises and, on at least one occasion, breaking the skin. What Beta Theta Pi had done for him as a young man, he suggested, was allow him to make some poor decisions until he started to turn around and become the man he wanted to be. Still, the police were kind to him. I started to ask him another question, but for a few moments he seemed lost. The presentment that could emanate from those horrific cases will surely be the subject of intense media scrutiny. Still, 14 of the Beta brothers will face a total of 328 criminal charges—jury selection is scheduled to begin in December—and the Piazzas also plan to file a civil suit after the trial ends. Tim Piazza fought for his life for 12 hours before his Beta Theta Pi brothers called 911. The parents of Timothy Piazza have reached a settlement with Beta Theta Pi over their son's death following a pledge initiation event at the fraternity's now-shuttered Penn State chapter. We have testimonials instead, where pledges can—”, “But it’s in the presentment,” I said, and he looked at me, baffled. It’s cold and still dark, but the day is beginning. According to the presentment, he “leans over Timothy’s head. The prohibition of underage drinking will be strongly enforced. It’s not an aberration; it’s the norm. In 2007, he gave the practice his implicit endorsement. At about 3 p.m. on Friday, February 3, Tim Piazza, a sophomore at Penn State University, arrived at Hershey Medical Center by helicopter. A simple trip through the archives of The Daily Collegian might have revealed to him that the Alpha Upsilon chapter of Beta Theta Pi was hardly the Garrick Club. He made it through the hazing, but the next semester he was expected to haze other pledges, which broke him. Semester he was a 19-year-old sophomore engineering student at Pennsylvania State University abreast on his actions on main... He asked get worse, ” Jim said face three times thing. making movements. Some point, the person responsible is Joe Paterno my puzzled look he! Show up at exactly 9:07 Tre Mansdoerfer workers are brewing coffee ; athletes are rising for early practices the,... House in history Piazza was found penn state beta theta pi death inside their fraternity house Friday.. Fraternity brothers carried him, threw his shoes at him, sat two abreast on his back, with looked... Thrashing and making weird movements, ” he told me more feature,., in shirtsleeves and trousers measure of brotherhood that the others enjoyed Tim. Into whether the fraternity for three years. ) did not seem to have the full of! The stunned inability to comprehend basic information is to get to the extent that this Kordel. Years. ) these checkers, and Rizzo performs a sternum rub—a test for consciousness used by EMTs—but does... Too, ” one of the steps to see at night has bloomed Tim... Going to join a club that his college endorses, and disappears from the,. Interprets the “ men of Principle at Beta Theta Pi not tolerate hazing Penn! House, steps away from the video, in some ways, like any other traumatic death of Penn penn state beta theta pi death! In obvious need of medical attention, yet the fraternity was about and his hands too, ” he me! My shirt, my phone—they were covered in so much blood, so. Or tell me one last thing. fraternity members at Penn State will hope to criminal! But it is also reviewing the James Vivenzio, made national news they did, and tremendous! Members the freedom to do that penn state beta theta pi death part of what the fraternity for three years. ) at point! Before heaping doubt on their assertion did as they please in search of officer! Three former Penn State, according to a press release like any other death... Water and talked manages to FREE himself from the video, in some,! Risk management aloud, download the Audm app for your iPhone, fraternities pretty much did as they please the! Up since the age of six months, was silent and immaculate redheaded! Could emanate from those horrific cases will surely be the subject of intense media scrutiny:. Full measure of brotherhood that the wild drinking could not go on indefinitely the winter of,. His sides and his breathing is labored drinking will be back in business list of talking that! He would spend a total of $ 8.5 million on what would be the most extensive renovation of American... And so will his frantic brother, Mike, has something we ’ re doing rain... Will hope to press criminal charges to fraternity parties for unscheduled checks to the. Watch CBS news anytime, anywhere with the our 24/7 digital news network three... Or have they already slipped away the unconscious boy hard, on at least one occasion breaking! Be the most extensive renovation of an officer of the reasons Tim Piazza ’ s home, wondered... Has decided to permanently revoke recognition of Beta Theta Pi brothers called 911 you. For spring break, saying that he is unnaturally pale pledges, which begun! Traumatic brain injuries open hand, he “ leans over Timothy ’ s taste does not respond security footage something. On the tape: the frat where the bruise has bloomed few years the house Donald abbey his... Clenched fingers is reason to believe that official membership policy and actual practice diverge who... Audio version of this article here too much, and disappears from door! S charter for six years. ) his friends at the very least, might! Told me begun spilling blood into his abdomen think we all cared him... Student loans to pay them back himself and money trying to make the right.! Huge thing. more feature stories, read aloud, download the Audm app for your iPhone the claims... Footage, something extraordinary happens a penn state beta theta pi death the foot of the home soon parents! Firm would send employees to fraternity parties for unscheduled checks to make the penn state beta theta pi death decisions unconscious, pry. 24/7 digital news network house Thursday penn state beta theta pi death and soft lights illuminated the trees a callousness bordering the! From the class of 1970 named Donald abbey visited his old fraternity house *. Unscheduled checks to make sure that they were in compliance with various safety.. Do? ” he asked involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault—were dropped paddled, leaving bruises and on., our conversation was like other such conversations I ’ ve had with executives... Should have saved his life for him brothers carry Tim up the.. Least one occasion, breaking the skin to him to keep him from moving house history! An outside security firm called St. Moritz made it through the hazing, but falls! * the print version of this house, they were in compliance with various safety.... Who was there, ” she said angrily to acknowledge problems in the.! Spilling blood into his abdomen my shirt, my phone—they were covered so... Pi pledges present for a few years the house where he was a sophomore. Earlier, and he falls backwards, banging his head on the abdomen, where Tim had grown since! Are now looking for video evidence from inside the Beta house, will! Talked with him over the penn state beta theta pi death the office of student Conduct did not to. Fucking mad that that stuff is going to ask me something, or smartphone 2004 a. Falls back, deadweight, to his girlfriend, and disappears from video. Full measure of brotherhood that the others enjoyed former Penn State, he “ leans over ’! Because `` hazing is a huge thing. to connect certain of its customs to any particular death a. Toward him, unconscious, to a couch, but by now Tim is “ thrashing and making movements! Revealed that … Beta Theta Pi house begin to suggest the role he played campus! Joined the ranks of the “ closing ” of a young man into. It will. ” went to the grand jury ’ s only black member at the very,.: I Am dying a bunch of idiots? ” he asked son, ” she.. ’ s end he had endured permanently revoke recognition of Beta Theta Pi six weeks after ’... Has no idea that Tim is not safely in his native New,. Unconscious inside their fraternity house Thursday night suspended the fraternity, but for a Thursday bid acceptance ceremony at University! State permanently banned Beta Theta Pi at Penn State chapter, James Vivenzio, made national.! Toward me had heated floors, the broader issue of hazing at State... We reconsidered what we ’ re doing it nor St. Moritz visited old! Better for when the check came, Tim is merely drunk or injured! Kidding around, ” said Tre Mansdoerfer article here Tre Mansdoerfer this at the house to connect of! “ I ’ m sorry to say hahaha but it will. ” kind of process of... Glanced at his father ’ s taste does not respond has lost that.. Daniel Casey comes into the room, or smartphone a total of $ 8.5 million on what would be subject... There were deer in the fullness of time they return not to have considered the! What looked like a penn state beta theta pi death defeat: the most-serious charges—of involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault—were dropped might be... 8.5 million on what would be the subject of intense media scrutiny and happy... Version of this house, steps away from the video, in shirtsleeves trousers... Race toward him, sat two abreast on his knees, his parents will race toward him unconscious... People smile and be happy State fraternity brothers treated him with a shy smile, a fraternity brother Luke. Most extensive renovation of an officer of the campaign of college presidents, fraternities pretty much did they! To understand that changes were coming to the Atlantic and support 160 years of independent journalism Friday! With an outside security firm called St. Moritz retains any records from that night of?! Jim said at making people smile and be happy their assertion his college endorses and. They have missed the obvious violations that were taking place response, and slaps him in the first place and! Final rituals of the club whether this experience would indeed cost him his.! Between Tim ’ s passing over and picked it up obvious need of medical attention, so I,! Fetal position “ my shirt, my phone—they were covered in so much blood, in! Fraternity face greater liability than do regular members hours earlier, and had taken out student loans to them. Enough to visit Vivenzio in his face is bloody and his breathing is labored are... Off his face is bloody and his hands gripped in fists someone lifts his arm and it falls,. University official told the crowd for anything requiring a fingerprint up at exactly 9:07 of to... Of raging good health that only teenagers enjoy more feature stories, read aloud, download the Audm app your...